In 2004, Hilarie got married to Ian Prange. Ian Prange is an assistant director and he is known for his work in the TV series, One Tree Hill. As a married couple, they remained together for about half a decade and they finally got divorced in 2009.
Soon after Hilarie got divorced with Ian Prange, she began dating Jeffrey Dean Morgan. Jeffrey Dean Morgan is also a famous actor and he is popular for starring his role in the TV series, Grey’s Anatomy. Within a year after she began dating him, she gave birth to their first child together. They got engaged in 2012 and finally got married in 2014.
Hilarie was raised in upper middle class family. She was raised along with her three brothers. She attended Park View High School and finally graduated from there in 2000. When she was there she also served as a student council treasurer. After her graduation, she got enrolled at New York University and Fordham University. While she was still attending her high school, she joined MTV where she served as a VJ for the Total Request Live. Within the short time, she got the permanent job there as the presenter of their show, 2000 MTV Video Music Awards. In 2002, she appeared in the TV series Dawson's Creek and Birds of Prey. She appeared in her first feature movie role in 2005 and that was in the movie, Our Very Own. Her net worth is said to be around $1 million.